November 2026
With the midterm elections in the rearview mirror, it’s a good opportunity not only to reflect on what happened, but also to inject some accountability into the world of prognostication, using a year’s worth of Impact columns as a guide.
“Trump’s support has slipped to the point where Republicans risk losing not just swing states and districts, but also some traditionally GOP areas where Democrats haven’t won in years, decades, even generations.” — October 2026, Failure of Imagination
While I wrote this just a few weeks before the election, it was spot-on. The bottom fell out from under Republicans in the final weeks as President Donald Trump’s negative job approval rating sank GOP candidates in Michigan, Georgia and North Carolina, but Democrats also won in Kansas, Mississippi, South Carolina and Texas. And, in the end, some of the races weren’t even close. Democratic state Rep. James Talarico won the Senate race in Texas by double digits. No one was predicting that.
“[If] Democratic state Rep. Angie Nixon is running even remotely close to GOP Sen. Ashley Moody and the race is too close to call early — or GOP Rep. Byron Donalds isn’t quickly projected as the winner in the gubernatorial race over former Rep. David Jolly — that’s a sign that 2026 is going to be very different from 2024.” — September 2026, Best State to Watch
This was definitely true. Despite a lack of national resources and attention, Nixon came within 3 points of defeating Moody, and Donalds only won by less than 2 points. That was indeed a sign of a much bigger night for Democrats in which they gained six governorships, at least eight Senate seats and more than 40 House seats nationwide. Watching the Florida margins was key.
“Control of the Senate may hinge on an incumbent who isn’t even on the ballot this November. And while there was a Ferris wheel on the National Mall this summer in the shadow of the Capitol, everyone in Washington might be on a roller coaster this winter.” — July/August 2026, Following Fetterman
This didn’t end up materializing. Because Democrats won so many Senate seats and easily cleared the four they needed to gain a majority, the world isn’t focused on whether Democratic Sen. John Fetterman of Pennsylvania switches parties or leaves the Democratic caucus. I will reiterate my other point though: This will be Fetterman’s final two years in Congress. He can’t win a Democratic primary because he has frustrated too many Democrats, and he can’t win a Republican primary because he’s too liberal for most GOP voters. So he can still be a wild card on the Hill.
“Some of the most common phrases in Washington and in politics are things like, ‘Five months is an eternity in politics,’ or ‘A lot can happen between now and the elections.’ While all of those things might technically be true, the reality is that voter sentiment most often changes gradually. In other words, yes, there are lots of news events that happen over the course of weeks and months, but that’s different than shifting political conditions. In most cases, the party that’s saying, ‘there’s still time,’ is often the party that is losing. And right now, that’s still the GOP.” — June 2026, Time Is Ticking Away
This was also definitely true. Republicans technically had time to turn things around and motivate their base. But that didn’t happen. Time only made things worse for the GOP as Trump’s job approval rating continued to decline throughout the year. So while it’s technically possible for the trajectory of a cycle to change dramatically, it often does not.
WE WANT TO HEAR FROM YOU
What are your reflections on the midterms? How do you see the outcome shaping your work?
Send your responses to [email protected]
“Considering President Donald Trump’s mediocre job rating (40% approve and 57% disapprove in the latest Nate Silver national average), the GOP is at considerable risk of losing its majorities in the House and Senate this November. But the bigger challenge for Republicans will be the state of the party once Trump isn’t at center stage. That difficult transition to the post-Trump GOP isn’t getting nearly enough attention.” — April 2026, Post-Trump Leadership
Now in the aftermath of the midterms, this question about the post-Trump Republican Party is even more relevant. How the GOP base wrestles with the extensive losses, and how much it blames the president and his policies, will help determine who the party turns to when it’s time for new leadership. Right now, GOP primary voters are cooler on Trump than they’ve been in years, but it’s not clear whether they want to continue in the same vein or take a different direction.
“It’s possible that sentiment about the economy and country could improve, and it’s possible that Trump’s job rating gets better. But as Republicans are in a pretty big hole, those sentiments are difficult to improve quickly, and the clock is ticking on the elections.” — January 2026, Early Outlook
Similar to June, the point is that it is extremely difficult for a party to have a midcycle course correction. So while it’s good to stay open-minded about various outcomes, and the most recent returns were bigger and bluer than expected, Republicans were on the defensive most of the cycle and the results should not have been a complete surprise.
Nathan L. Gonzales is a senior political analyst for the Public Affairs Council and editor of Inside Elections, a nonpartisan newsletter with a subscription package designed to boost PACs with a regular newsletter and exclusive conference call. You can also hear more on the Inside Elections Podcast. His email address is [email protected].
“
How the GOP base wrestles with the extensive losses, and how much it blames the president and his policies, will help determine who the party turns to when it’s time for new leadership.
More News & Resources
A new transatlantic program bringing public affairs professionals in Washington, D.C., and Brussels together in real time.